Problem Ix Violet's Own

"It has been too much for you?"

"I am afraid so."

It was Roger Upjohn who had asked the question; it was Violet who

answered. They had withdrawn from a crowd of dancers to a

balcony, half-shaded, half open to the moon,--a balcony made, it

would seem, for just such stolen interviews between waltzes.

Now, as it happened, Roger's face was in the shadow, but Violet's

the full light. Very sweet it looked, very ethereal, but also

a little wan. He noticed this and impetuously cried:

"You are pale; and your hand! see, how it trembles!"

Slowly withdrawing it from the rail where it had rested, she sent

one quick glance his way and, in a low voice, said:

"I have not slept since that night."

"Four days!" he murmured. Then, after a moment of silence, "You

bore yourself so bravely at the time, I thought, or rather, I

hoped, that success had made you forget the horror. I could not

have slept myself, if I had known--"

"It is part of the price I pay," she broke in gently. "All good

things have to be paid for. But I see--I realize that you do not

consider what I am doing good. Though it helps other people--has

helped you--you wonder why, with all the advantages I possess, I

should meddle with matters so repugnant to a woman's natural


Yes, he wondered. That was evident from his silence. Seeing her

as she stood there, so quaintly pretty, so feminine in look and

manner--in short, such a flower--it was but natural that he

should marvel at the incongruity she had mentioned.

"It has a strange, odd look," she admitted, after a moment of

troubled hesitation. "The most considerate person cannot but

regard it as a display of egotism or of a most mercenary spirit.

The cheque you sent me for what I was enabled to do for you in

Massachusetts (the only one I have ever received which I have

been tempted to refuse) shows to what extent you rated my help

and my--my expectations. Had I been a poor girl struggling for

subsistence, this generosity would have warmed my heart as a

token of your desire to cut that struggle short. But taken with

your knowledge of my home and its luxuries, it has often made me

wonder what you thought."

"Shall I tell you?"

He had stepped forward at this question and his countenance,

hitherto concealed, became visible in the moonlight. She no

longer recognized it. Transformed by feeling, it shone down upon

her, instinct with all that is finest and best in masculine

nature. Was she ready for this revelation of what she had

nevertheless dreamed of for many more nights than four? She did

not know, and instinctively drew herself back till it was she who

now stood in the semi-obscurity made by the drooping vines. From

this retreat, she faltered forth a very tremulous No, which in

another moment was disavowed by a Yes so faint it was little more

than a murmur, followed by a still fainter, Tell me.

But he did not seem in any haste to obey, sweetly as her low-

toned injunction must have sounded in his ears. On the contrary,

he hesitated to speak, growing paler every minute as he sought to

catch a glimpse of her downcast face so tantalizingly hidden from

him. Did she recognize the nature of the feelings which held him

back, or was she simply gathering up sufficient courage to plead

her own cause? Whatever her reason, it was she, not he, who

presently spoke saying as if no time had elapsed:

"But first, I feel obliged to admit that it was money I wanted,

that I had to have. Not for myself. I lack nothing and could have

more if I wished. Father has never limited his generosity in any

matter affecting myself, but--" She drew a deep breath and,

coming out of the shadow, lifted a face to him so changed from

its usual expression as to make him start. "I have a cause at

heart--one which should appeal to my father and does not; and for

that purpose I have sacrificed myself, in many ways, though--

though I have not disliked my work up to this last attempt. Not

really. I want to be honest and so must admit that much. I have

even gloried (quietly and all by myself, of course) over the

solution of a mystery which no one else seemed able to penetrate.

I am made that way. I have known it ever since--but that is a

story all by itself. Some day I may tell it to you, but not now."

"No, not now." The emphasis sent the colour into her cheek but

did not relieve his pallor. "Miss Strange, I have always felt,

even in my worst days, that the man who for selfish ends brought

a woman under the shadow of his own unhappy reputation was a man

to be despised. And I think so still, and yet--and yet--nothing

in the world but your own word or look can hold me back now from

telling you that I love you--love you notwithstanding my unworthy

past, my scarring memories, my all but blasted hopes. I do not

expect any response; you are young; you are beautiful; you are

gifted with every grace; but to speak,--to say over and over

again, 'I love you, I love you!' eases my heart and makes my

future more endurable. Oh, do not look at me like that unless--


But the bright head did not fall, nor the tender gaze falter; and

driven out of himself, Roger Upjohn was about to step

passionately forward, when, seized by fresh compunction, he

hoarsely cried:

"It is not right. The balance dips too much my way. You bring me

everything. I can give you nothing but what you already possess

abundance--love, and money. Besides, your father--"

She interrupted him with a glance at once arch and earnest.

"I had a talk with Father this morning. He came to my room, and--

and it was very near being serious. Someone had told him I was

doing things on the sly which he had better look into; and of

course he asked questions and--and I answered them. He wasn't

pleased--in fact he was very displeased,--I don't think we can

blame him for that--but we had no open break for I love him

dearly, for all my opposing ways, and he saw that, and it helped,

though he did say after I had given my promise to stop where I

was and never to take up such work again, that--" here she stole

a shy look at the face bent so eagerly towards her--"that I had

lost my social status and need never hope now for the attentions

of--of--well, of such men as he admires and puts faith in. So you

see," her dimples all showing, "that I am not such a very good

match for an Upjohn of Massachusetts, even if he has a reputation

to recover and an honourable name to achieve. The scale hangs

more evenly than you think."


A mutual look, a moment of perfect silence, then a low whisper,

airy as the breath of flowers rising from the garden below: "I

have never known what happiness was till this moment. If you will

take me with my story untold--"

"Take you! take you!" The man's whole yearning heart, the loss

and bitterness of years, the hope and promise of the future, all

spoke in that low, half-smothered exclamation. Violet's blushes

faded under its fervency, and only her spirit spoke, as leaning

towards him, she laid her two hands in his, and said with all a

woman's earnestness:

"I do not forget little Roger, or the father who I hope may have

many more days before him in which to bid good-night to the sea.

Such union as ours must be hallowed, because we have so many

persons to make happy besides ourselves."

The evening before their marriage, Violet put a dozen folded

sheets of closely written paper in his hand. They contained her

story; let us read it with him.


I could not have been more than seven years old, when one night I

woke up shivering, at the sound of angry voices. A conversation

which no child should ever have heard, was going on in the room

where I lay. My father was talking to my sister--perhaps, you do

not know that I have a sister; few of my personal friends do,--

and the terror she evinced I could well understand but not his

words nor the real cause of his displeasure.

There are times even yet when the picture, forced upon my

infantile consciousness at that moment of first awakening, comes

back to me with all its original vividness. There was no light in

the room save such as the moon made; but that was enough to

reveal the passion burningly alive in either face, as, bending

towards each other, she in supplication and he in a tempest of

wrath which knew no bounds, he uttered and she listened to what I

now know to have been a terrible arraignment.

I may have an interesting countenance; you have told me so

sometimes; but she--she was beautiful. My elder by ten years, she

had stood in my mother's stead to me for almost as long as I

could remember, and as I saw her lovely features contorted with

pain and her hands extended in a desperate plea to one who had

never shown me anything but love, my throat closed sharply and I

could not cry out though I wanted to, nor move head or foot

though I longed with all my heart to bury myself in the pillows.

For the words I heard were terrifying, little as I comprehended

their full purport. He had surprised her talking from her window

to someone down below, and after saying cruel things about that,

he shouted out: "You have disgraced me, you have disgraced

yourself, you have disgraced your brother and your little sister.

Was it not enough that you should refuse to marry the good man I

had picked out for you, that you should stoop to this low-down

scoundrel--this--" I did not hear what else he called him, I was

wondering so to whom she had been stooping; I had never seen her

stoop except to tie my little shoes.

But when she cried out as she did after an interval, "I love him!

I love him!" then I listened again, for she spoke as though she

were in dreadful pain, and I did not know that loving made one

ill and unhappy. "And I am going to marry him," I heard her add,

standing up, as she said it, very straight and tall.

Marry! I knew what that meant. A long aisle in a church; women in

white and big music in the air behind. I had been flower-girl at

a wedding once and had not forgotten. We had had ice cream and

cake and--

But my childish thoughts stopped short at the answer she received

and all the words which followed--words which burned their way

into my infantile brain and left scorched places in my memory

which will never be eradicated. He spoke them--spoke them all;

she never answered again after that once, and when he was gone

did not move for a long time and when she did it was to lie down,

stiff and straight, just as she had stood, on her bed alongside


I was frightened; so frightened, my little brass bed rattled

under me. I wonder she did not hear it. But she heard nothing;

and after awhile she was so still I fell asleep. But I woke

again. Something hot had fallen on my cheek. I put up my hand to

brush it away and did not know even when I felt my fingers wet

that it was a tear from my sister-mother's eye.

For she was kneeling then; kneeling close beside me and her arm

was over my small body; and the bed was shaking again but not

this time with my tremors only. And I was sorry and cried too

until I dropped off to sleep again with her arm still

passionately embracing me.

In the morning, she was gone.

It must have been that very afternoon that Father came in where

Arthur and I were trying to play,--trying, but not quite

succeeding, for I had been telling Arthur, for whom I had a great

respect in those days, what had happened the night before, and we

had been wondering in our childish way if there would be a

wedding after all, and a church full of people, and flowers, and

kissing, and lots of good things to eat, and Arthur had said No,

it was too expensive; that that was why Father was so angry; and

comforted by the assertion, I was taking up my doll again, when

the door opened and Father stepped in.

It was a great event--any visit from him to the nursery--and we

both dropped our toys and stood staring, not knowing whether he

was going to be nice and kind as he sometimes was, or scold us as

I had heard him scold our beautiful sister.

Arthur showed at once what he thought, for without the least

hesitation he took the one step which placed him in front of me,

where he stood waiting with his two little fists hanging straight

at his sides but manfully clenched in full readiness for attack.

That this display of pigmy chivalry was not quite without its

warrant is evident to me now, for Father did not look like

himself or act like himself any more than he had the night


However, we had no cause for fear. Having no suspicion of my

having been awake during his terrible interview with Theresa, he

saw only two lonely and forsaken children, interrupted in their


Can I remember what he said to us? Not exactly, though Arthur and

I often went over it choked whispers in some secret nook of the

dreary old house; but his meaning--that we took in well enough.

Theresa had left us. She would never come back. We were not to

look out of the window for her, or run to the door when the bell

rang. Our mother had left us too, a long time ago, and she lay in

the cemetery where we sometimes carried flowers. Theresa was not

in the cemetery, but we must think of her as there; though not as

if she had any need of flowers. Having said this, he looked at

us quietly for a minute. Arthur was trying very hard not to cry,

but I was sobbing like the lost child I was, with my cheek

against the floor where I had thrown myself when he said that

awful thing about the cemetery. She there! my sister-mother

there! I think he felt a little sorry for me; for he half stooped

as if to lift me up. But he straightened again and said very


"Now, children, listen to me. When God takes people to heaven and

leaves us only their cold, dead bodies we carry flowers to their

graves and talk about them some if not very much. But when people

die because they love dark ways better than light, then we do not

remember them with gifts and we do not talk about them. Your

sister's name has been spoken for the last time in this house.

You, Arthur, are old enough to know what I mean when I say that I

will never listen to another word about her from either you or

Violet as long as you and I live. She is gone and nothing that is

mine shall she ever touch again.

"You hear me, Arthur; you hear me, Violet. Heed me, or you go


His aspect was terrible, so was his purpose; much more terrible

than we realized at the time with our limited understanding and

experience. Later, we came to know the full meaning of this black

drop which had been infused into our lives. When we saw every

picture of her destroyed which had been in the house; her name

cut out from the leaves of books; the little tokens she had given

us surreptitiously taken away, till not a vestige of her once

beloved presence remained, we began to realize that we had indeed

lost her.

But children as young as we were then do not long retain the

poignancy of their first griefs. Gradually my memories of that

awful night ceased to disturb my dreams and I was sixteen before

they were again recalled to me with any vividness, and then it

was by accident. I had been strolling through a picture gallery

and had stopped short to study more particularly one which had

especially taken my fancy. There were two ladies sitting on a

bench behind me and one of them was evidently very deaf, for

their talk was loud, though I am sure they did not mean for me to

hear, for they were discussing my family. That is, one of them

had said:

"That's Violet Strange. She will never be the beauty her sister

was; but perhaps that's not to be deplored. Theresa made a great

mess of it."

"That's true. I hear that she and the Signor have been seen

lately here in town. In poverty, of course. He hadn't even as

much go in him as the ordinary singing-master."

I suppose I should have hurried away, and left this barbed arrow

to rankle where it fell. But I could not. I had never learned a

word of Theresa's fate and that word poverty, proving that she

was alive and suffering, held me to my place to hear what more

they might say of her who for years had been for me an indistinct

figure bathed in cruel moonlight.

"I have never approved of Peter Strange's conduct at that time,"

one of the voices now went on. "He didn't handle her right. She

had a lovely disposition and would have listened to him had he

been more gentle with her. But it isn't in him. I hope this one--"

I didn't hear the end of that. I had no interest in anything they

might say about myself. It was of her I wanted to hear, of her.

Weren't they going to say anything more about my poor sister?

Yes; it was a topic which interested both and presently I heard:

"He'll never do anything for her, no matter what happens; I've

heard him say so. And Laura has vowed the same." (Laura is our

aunt.) "Besides, Theresa has a pride of her own quite equal to

her father's. She wouldn't take anything from him now. She'd

rather struggle on. I'm told--I don't know how true it is--that

she's working in a department store; one of the Sixth Avenue

ones. Oh, there's Mrs. Vandegraff! Don't you want to speak to


They moved off, leaving me still gazing with unseeing eyes at

the picture before which I stood planted, and saying over and

over in monotonous iteration, "One of the department stores in

Sixth Avenue! One of the department stores in Sixth Avenue!"

Which department store?

I meant to find out.

I do not know whether up till then I had had the least

consciousness of possessing what is called the detective

instinct. But, at the prospect of this quest, so much like that

of the proverbial needle in a haystack, as I did not even know my

sister's married name and something within me forbade my asking

it, I experienced an odd sense of elation followed by a certainty

of success which in five minutes changed me from an irresponsible

girl to a woman with a deliberate purpose in life.

I am not going to write down here all the details of that search.

Some day I may relate them to you, but not now. I looked first

for a beautiful woman, for the straight, slim, and exquisite

creature I remembered. I did not find her. Then I tried another

course. Her figure might have changed in the ten years which had

elapsed; so might her expression. I would look for a woman with

beautiful dark eyes; time could not have altered them. I had

forgotten the effect of constant weeping. And I saw many eyes,

but not hers; not the ones I had seen smiling upon me as I lay in

my crib before the days I was lifted to the dignity of the little

brass bed. So I gave that up too and listened to the inner voice

which said, "You must wait for her to recognize you. You can

never hope to recognize her." And it was by following this plan

that I found her. I had arranged to have my name spoken aloud at

every counter where I bargained; and oh, the bargains I sought,

and the garments I had tried on! But I made little progress until

one day, after my name had been uttered a little louder than

usual I saw a woman turn from rearranging gowns on a hanger, and

give me one look.

I uttered a low cry and sprang impetuously, forward. Instantly

she turned her back and went on hanging, or trying to hang up,

gowns on the rack before her. Had I been mistaken? She was not

the sister of my dreams, but there was something fine in her

outline; something distinguished in the way she carried her head


Next minute my last doubt fled! She had fallen her length on the

floor and lay with her face buried in her hands in a dead faint.

Oh, Roger, Roger, Roger! I had that dear head on my breast in a

moment. I talked to her, I whispered prayers in her unconscious

ear. I did everything I should not have done till they all

thought me demented. When she came to, as she did under other

ministrations than mine, I was for carrying her off in my

limousine. But she shook her head with a gesture of such

disapproval, that I realized I could not do that. The limousine

was my father's, and nothing of his was ever to be used for her

again. I would call a cab; but she told me that she had not the

money to pay for it and she would not take mine. Carfare she had;

five cents would take her home. I need not worry.

She smiled as she said this and for an instant I saw my dream-

sister again in this weary half-disheartened woman. But the smile

was a fleeting one, for this was to be her last day in the store;

she had no talent as a saleswoman and was merely working out her


I felt my heart sink heavily at this, for the evidences of

poverty were plainly to be seen in her clothes and the thinness

of her face and figure. How could I help? What could I do? I took

her to a restaurant for food and talk, and before she would

order, she looked into her purse, with the result that we had

only a little toast and tea. It was all she could afford and I,

with a hundred dollars in bills at that moment in my bag, could

not offer her anything more though she was needing nourishment

and dishes piled with savoury meats were going by us every


I think, if she had let me, I would have dared my father's

displeasure and been disobedient to his wishes by giving her one

wholesome meal. But she was as resolute of mind as he, and, as

she said afterwards, had chosen her course in life and must abide

by it. My love she would accept. It took nothing from Father and

gave her what her heart was pining for--had pined for for years.

But nothing more--not another thing more. She would not even let

me go home with her; and I knew why when her eyes fell at the

searching look I gave her. Something would turn up, and when her

husband's health was better and she had found another position

she would send me her address and then I could come and see her.

As we walked out of the restaurant we ran against a gentleman I

knew. He stopped me for a passing word and in that minute she

disappeared. I did not try to follow her. I could get her street

and number from the store where she had worked.

But when I had done this and embraced the first opportunity which

offered to visit her, I found that she had moved away in the

interim, leaving everything behind in payment of her rent, except

such small things as she and her husband could carry. This was

discouraging as it left me without any clue by which to follow

them. But I was determined not to yield to her desire for

concealment in the difficult and disheartening task I now saw

before me.

Seeking advice from the man who has since become my employer, I

entered upon this second search with a quiet resolution which

admitted of no defeat. It took me six months, but I finally found

her, and satisfied with knowing where she was, desisted from

rushing in upon her, till I had caught one glimpse of her husband

whom, in the last six months, I had heard described but had never

seen. To understand her, it was perhaps necessary to understand

him, and if I could not hope to do this offhand, I could not fail

to get some idea of the man from even the most casual look.

He was, as I soon learned, the fetcher and carrier of the small

ménage; and the day came when I met him face to face in the

street where they lived. Did he disappoint me; or did I see

something in his appearance to justify her desertion of her

father's home and her present life of poverty? If I say Yes to

the first question, I must also say it to the last. If handsome

once, he was not handsome now; but with a personality such as

his, this did not matter. He had that better thing--that greatest

gift of the gods--charm. It was in his bearing, his movement, the

regard of his weary eye; more than that it was in his very nature

or it would have vanished long ago under disappointment and


But that was all there was to the man,--a golden net in which my

sister's youthful fancy had been caught and no doubt held meshed

to this very day. I felt less like blaming her for her folly,

after that instant's view of him as we passed each other in the

street. But, as I took time to think, I found myself growing

sorrier and sorrier for her and yet, in a way, gladder and

gladder, for the man was a physical wreck and would soon pass out

of her life leaving her to my love and possibly to our father's


But I did not know Theresa. After her husband's death, which

occurred very soon, she let me come to her and we had a long talk--

Shall I ever forget it or the sight of her beauty in that sordid

room? For, account for it as you will, the loveliness which had

fled under her sense of complete isolation had slowly regained

its own with the recognition that she still had a place in the

heart of her little sister. Not even the sorrow she felt for the

loss of her suffering husband--and she did mourn him; this I am

glad to say--could more than temporarily stay this. Six months of

ease and wholesome food would make her--I hardly dared to think

what. For I knew, without asking her, or she telling me, that she

would accept neither; that she was as determined now, as ever

that nothing which came directly or indirectly from Father should

go to the rebuilding of her life. That she intended to start anew

and work her way up to a place where I should be glad to see her

she did say. But nothing more. She was still the sister-mother,

loving, but sufficient to herself, though she had but ten dollars

left in the world, as she showed me with a smile that made her

beautiful as an angel.

I can see that shabby little purse yet with its one poor greasy

bill;--a sum to her but to me the price of a luncheon or a gift

of flowers. How I longed, as I looked at it to tear every jewel

from my poor, bedecked body and fling them one and all into her

lap. I had worn them in profusion, though carefully hidden under

my coat, in the hope that she would accept one of them at least,

But she refused all, even such as had been gifts of friends and

schoolmates, only humouring me this far, that she let me hang

them for a few minutes about her neck and in her hair and then

pull them all off again. But this one vision of her in the

splendour she was born to comforted me. Henceforth in wearing

them it would be of her and not of myself I should think.

Well, I had to leave her and go home to my French and Italian

lessons, my music-masters and all the luxuries of our father's

house. Should I ever see her again? I did not know; she had not

promised. I could not go often into the quarter where she lived,

without rousing suspicion; and she had bidden me not to come

again for a month. So I waited, half fearing she would flit again

before the month was up. But she did not. She was still there


But I am going too fast. The meeting I was about to mention was a

very memorable one to me, and I must describe it from the

beginning. I had ridden in my own car as near as I dared to the

street where she lived; the rest of the way I went on foot with

one of the servants--a new one--following close behind me. I was

not exactly afraid, but the actions of some of the people I had

encountered at my former visit warned me to be a little careful

for my father's sake if not for my own. Her room--she had but one

--was high up in a triangular court it was no pleasure to enter.

But love and loyalty heed nothing but the object sought, and I

was hunting about for the dark doorway which opened upon the

staircase leading to her room when--and this was the great moment

of my life--a sudden stream of melody floated down into that

noisome court, which from its clearness, its accuracy, its

richness, and its feeling startled me as I had never before been

startled even by the first notes of the world's greatest singers.

What a voice for a place like this! What a voice for any place!

Whose could it be? With a start, I stopped short, in the middle

of that court, heedless of the crowd of pushing, shouting

children who at once gathered about me. I had been struck by an

old recollection. My sister used to sing. I remembered where her

piano had stood in the great drawing-room. It had been carted

away during those dreadful weeks and her music all burned; but

the vision of her graceful figure bending over the keyboard was

one not to be forgotten even by a thoughtless child. Could it be--

oh, heaven! if this voice were hers! Her future was certain; she

had but to sing.

In a transport of hope I rushed for the dim entrance the children

had pointed out and flew up to her room. As I reached it, I heard

a trill as perfect as Tetrazzini's. The singer was Theresa; there

could be no more doubt. Theresa! exercising a grand voice as only

a great artist would or could.

The joy of it made me almost faint. I leaned against her door and

sobbed. Then when I thought I could speak quite calmly, I went


Roger, you must understand me now,--my desire for money and the

means I have taken to obtain it. My sister had the makings of a

prima-donna. Her husband, of whose ability I had formed so low an

estimate, had trained her with consummate skill and judgment. All

she needed was a year with some great maestro in the foreign

atmosphere of art. But this meant money--not hundreds but

thousands, and the one sure source to which we might rightfully

look for any such amount was effectually closed to us. It is true

we had relatives--an aunt on our mother's side, and I mentioned

her to Theresa. But she would not listen to the suggestion. She

would take nothing from any one whom she would find it hard to

face in case of failure. Love must go with an advance involving

so much risk; love deep enough and strong enough to feel no loss

save that of a defeated hope. In short, to be acceptable, the

money must come from me, and as this was manifestly impossible,

she considered the matter closed and began to talk of a position

she had been offered in some choir. I let her talk, listening and

not listening; for the idea had come to me that if in some way I

could earn money, she might be induced to take it. Finally, I

asked her. She laughed, letting her kisses answer me. But I did

not laugh. If she had capabilities in one way, I had them in


I went home to think.

Two weeks later, I began, in a very quiet way to do certain work

for the man who had helped me in my second search for Theresa.

The money I have earned has been immense; since it was troubles

of the rich I was given to settle, and I was almost always

successful. Every cent has gone to her. She has been in Europe

for a year and last week she made her debut. You read about it in

the papers, but neither you nor any one else in this country but

myself knew that under the name she chosen to assume, Theresa

Strange, the long forgotten beauty, has recovered that place in

the world, to which her love and genius entitle her.

This is my story and hers. From now on, you are the third in the

secret. Some day, my father will be the fourth. I think then, a

new dawn of love will arise for us all, which will stay the

whitening of his dear head--for I believe in him after all.

Yesterday when he passed the wall where her picture once hung--

no other has ever hung there--I saw him stop and look up, and,

Roger, when he passed me a minute later, there was a tear in his

hard eye.